Critical Analysis: I think what is most enjoyable about this book is that it is set as a thriller story. The reader is so involved to see who will create the atomic bomb first and then what will happen if this new discovery gets in the wrong hands. Not only does Sheinkin offer a great plotline, but the reader is also privy to actual history. Sheinkin offers actual photographs throughout the story and ends his book with a source list and an incredible annotated bibliography to guide the reader towards the facts.
The only minor complaint and issue I can see with this book
is the number of characters. Since Sheinkin
tells the story from various perspectives, the reader may have a little trouble
keeping track of each character’s viewpoint.
Placing each character within the entire plotline can be confusing at
times.
Review Excerpts:
Horn Book: “Sheinkin here maintains the pace of a thriller without
betraying history (source notes and an annotated bibliography are exemplary) or
skipping over the science.”
Goodreads: “This is the story of the plotting, the risk-taking, the
deceit, and genius that created the world's most formidable weapon.”
Connections: Bomb would be an excellent introduction for secondary students a World War II unit. Since the story has such a thrilling plotline, students will immediately become interested in the stories to share. Groups of students could research further the creation of the atomic bomb and attempt to answer the ending question of if we should still have the atomic bomb.
Sheinkin created a follow up to Bomb with his book Fallout:
Spies, Superbombs and the Ultimate Cold War Showdown. Students could continue their research with
this novel and a familiar author.
Murphy, Jim. 1995. THE GREAT FIRE. New York: Scholastic. ISBN 9780439203074
Plot Summary: Murphy shares incredible nonfiction personal accounts that tell the story of the one of the greatest disasters in American history- the great fire of Chicago in 1871. The fire forced over 100,000 people to leave their homes in hopes to escape the fire. Murphy shares the stories of various survivors to retell the story among them the couple who owned the barn where the fire started, a widow who saved her five small children and elderly parents, a twelve-year-old girl, and others. Murphy’s readers get a true insight into what happened during and after that fateful disaster.
Critical Analysis: Readers will become more immersed in the details of this historic event while learning from different perspectives. Murphy not only offers the survivors’ stories, but does a good job of including historical photographs. He shows maps of the city to explain why the fire spread and shows photographs of the aftermath. Murphy’s underlying theme of even when disaster hits, people will struggle but will also triumph through.
Review Excerpts:
Kirkus: “With his conclusion that
the tensions between the haves and the have-nots in large cities continued for
decades, eventually culminating in the civil unrest of this century, he puts
the incident in perspective, giving it stunning immediacy for contemporary
readers.”
Publisher’s Weekly
Starred Review: “This volume, beautifully printed in sepia tones, contains
historic photos, engravings and newspaper clippings on nearly every page.”
Connections: When readers engage in this book, they will soon discover that there is a connection between the richer and poorer sides to Chicago. Scholars can dig deeper into the why of how this fire started and spread. Was there more wood structures that caused the fire to spread in certain areas? Did the wealthy have access to easier escape routes?
Scholars might enjoy other historical books written about
this event like the I Survived-The Great Chicago Fire by Lauren Tarshis
or Chicago’s Great Fire: The Destruction and Resurrection of an Iconic
American City by Carl Smith to locate other perspectives.
Fleming, Candace. 2005. OUR ELEANOR: A SCRAPBOOK LOOK AT ELEANOR ROOSEVELT’S REMARKABLE LIFE. New York: Simon & Schuster Children’s Publishing Division. ISBN: 9780689865442
Plot Summary: Fleming introduces this incredible first lady and her story through pictures, timelines, letters, and magazine articles in a way that most readers have never seen Eleanor Roosevelt. She begins with an introduction sharing how she jumped at the chance to write a biography on this iconic American lady. She tells the story of how she visited her hometown and heard stories of a close family friend to guide her in writing a biography that gives a full picture. Readers are walked through all areas of Eleanor’s life including childhood, her marriage, her life as a mother, life in the White House and after leaving the First Lady spotlight.
Critical Analysis: Fleming uses the look of a “scrapbook” to tell Eleanor Roosevelt’s story which includes professional photographs, but also shares smaller artifacts such as her school report cards. This “scrapbook” style makes this biography very easy to read and enjoy. The reader will feel like he or she has been immersed into the true story of this iconic First Lady.
Publisher’s Weekly (Starred Review): “… Fleming allows readers to draw their own
conclusions; they will come away with an understanding of a woman who shaped
her times and left a lasting imprint on the future.”
Connections: This scrapbook style biography will invite students to read more biographies. The ease of looking through pictures and artifacts make the reader feel more confident in reading historical documents. Readers will also enjoy Fleming’s scrapbook style in Benjamin Franklin’s Almanac. Students might also enjoy the “Who Was Series” of Eleanor Roosevelt for further information.
Plot Summary: This biographical picture books shares the story of Theodore Roosevelt’s oldest daughter Alice. The author walks you through her life beginning at birth when her mother passed away just a few days after she was born. She seems to be an unruly child and always seems to attract the wrong attention until she gets older. Her famous father may have had trouble keeping up with her antics, but Alice grows into a reliable woman who travels often to represent her country well.
Critical Analysis: A lot of readers may not consider a picture book to be a great example of a biography, but What To Do About Alice? defies initial expectations. Readers get a look into the life of a historical figure that may not otherwise be noticed. Most historians have focused on Alice’s father, Theodore Roosevelt. The reader learns about a young girl who defies odds such as losing her mother, leg braces, and learning how to live in the world’s spotlight as the President’s daughter.
Fotheringham’s illustrations show the playful side of Alice and
keep the reader engaged throughout the story.
On one of the pages, Kerley shares that Alice “helped” her stepmother by
taking care of her stepsiblings while the picture shows the kids sliding on mattresses. Even though the illustrations are simple, Fotheringham
does a great job of depicting the actual historical figures.
Kirkus: “Sprinkling her account with well-chosen quotations, she
outlines Alice Roosevelt Longworth’s childhood and its increasingly outrageous
hijinks, as well as the loving (if sometimes exasperating) relationship she
enjoyed with her renowned father.”
Publisher’s Weekly Starred Review: “It’s hard to imagine a
picture book biography that could better suit its subject than this high-energy
volume serves young Alice Roosevelt.”
Connections: This book could spark some research into how families handle living in the White House. When a person gets elected President of the United States, it’s not just the President that has a life changed. The family, which can include children, will have life-altering moments. Rebecca Behrens wrote a novel called When Audrey Met Alice where Audrey, a current First Daughter, finds a diary of Alice while living in the White House. Students could use both books to further explore the life of a First Child.